How Silence Culture Can Put Your Company at Risk

In many cultures, silence is a sign of hierarchy or respect. Sometimes, silence provides space so others can be heard. But there’s another side of silence people don’t talk about—silence culture. Silence culture and its effects create quantifiable risk and revenue loss for organizations. However, the upside of enabling, and preparing, for the use of employee and customer voice can be significant.

What is silence culture?

Silence culture is an environment where speaking up is neither encouraged nor rewarded. Within silence culture, speaking up carries a great deal of perceived or real consequences for employees. So, questions are not asked and risks are not pointed out. You may have heard silence culture referred to as “not making waves.”

What problems are caused by silence culture?

The problems caused by lack of disclosure can be significant. Our founder, Diane Dye, created the ID Framework for Non-Disclosure Risk, which is proprietary to People Risk Consulting, to explain the four types of disclosure silence culture discourages. This teaching framework has four components.

  • Incident Disclosure
  • Instructional Needs Disclosure
  • Idea Disclosure
  • Identity Disclosure

Incident Disclosure

Definition: The likelihood an individual would disclose the occurrence of an incident.

Problem: 50% of workplace injuries go unreported. Direct costs include workers’ compensation payments, medical expenses, and costs for legal services (OSHA, 2024). Delayed reporting and care for workplace injury can result in fines in some states or worsening of the condition including damage to tools, equipment, and other property (WCF Insurance, nd). It can also result in time lost for replacing damaged equipment, spoiled work, and loss of production.

What You Might See: Physical safety risks, legal risks, cover up of costly mistakes, waterfall effect of a series of small incidents leading to larger, and more costly, failures.

Who Cares: This is often the biggest focus organizations have when it comes to the use of employee or customer voice in the workplace. Safety managers, risk managers, occupational health and safety care about this.

Instructional Needs Disclosure

Definition: The likelihood an individual would disclose their need for instruction.

Problem: Poor employee training and lack of identification of gaps in understanding can lead to low productivity, inefficiency, poor customer service, high turnover, and low-quality outputs of services and products (The Training Associates, 2022)

What You Might See: Decreased customer satisfaction, increased customer churn, employee turnover, workplace injury

Who Cares: Learning and Development functions focus on closing gaps in instructional needs, although some current performance management processes and levels of psychological safety within business units do not support individual disclosure of instructional needs until a costly mistake is made and a reactive response is necessary. Operations executives also care if people, process, and systems align.

Idea Disclosure

Definition: The likelihood an individual would disclose an idea or the disagreement with an idea.

Problem: According to a Gallup survey, disengaged employees cost U.S. companies between $450 billion to $550 billion annually in lost productivity and is an $8.8 trillion global problem. Sustained lack of innovation can lead to high employee turnover, increased recruitment costs, and a negative impact on bottom-line results. Disengaged employees are less likely to go the extra mile for customers, leading to subpar customer experiences. 

What You Might See: Lack of data on voice of the employee (VOE) or voice of the customer (VOC), stunted innovation, employee turnover, employees leaving to take their ideas to the competition, loss of competitive advantage, failure to speak up about detrimental ideas or plans that could create incidents

Who Cares: CEO, Chief Customer Officer, human resources executives, Chief Revenue Officer, risk management, change management

Identity Disclosure

Definition: The likelihood an individual would disclose or defend their identity.

Problem: Identity problems in the workplace can include identity conflicts, social identity (belonging or lack thereof), and identity crisis. It can involve a lack of clarity about personal role or organizational culture alignment including one’s values, skills, interests, or sense of self. People problems spurring from identity are costly to organizations.

What You Might See: Employee withdrawal, disengagement, behavioral concerns, employee retention problems, increased complaints and investigation

Who Cares: Human Resources leaders, DE&I executives, risk managers interested in harassment, and other human issues

If you would like to understand the ID Framework for Non-Disclosure Risk and how PRC can help you apply it to your organization, connect with us on a quick inquiry call. Workshops, leadership training, and assessment services are available.


People Risk Consulting (PRC) is a human capital risk management and change management consulting firm located in San Antonio, Texas. PRC helps leaders in service-focused industries mitigate people risk by conducting third-party people-centric risk analysis and employee needs assessments. PRC analyzes and uses this data alongside best practice to make strategic recommendations to address organizational problems related to change and employee risk. The firm works alongside leaders to develop risk plans, change plans, and strategic plans to drive the human element of continuous improvement. PRC provides technical assistance, education, training, and trusted partner resources to aid with execution. PRC is a strategic partner of TriNet, Marsh McClennan Agency, Cloud Tech Gurus, Predictive Index, and Motivosity.

Quick Notes: Using Data to Mitigate Risk in Your Organization

Diane spoke with David Bryan, a leader in data engineering and cybersecurity, about how to aggregate and utilize data to inform organizational strategy.

In today’s rapidly evolving business landscape, data is not just a byproduct of operations; it’s the cornerstone of strategic decision-making. Recently, I had an engaging discussion that underscored the pivotal role data plays in driving customer success and sales enablement within software companies. We dove into some of the key challenges organizations face with the organization and utilization of data.

The Challenge of Data Siloes

One of the biggest hurdles organizations face is the siloed nature of their data. As we spoke David and I recognized that many companies struggle to integrate data across departments. This hampers their ability to make informed decisions for the organization as a whole. This issue is particularly pronounced in customer success functions, where data-driven decisions are crucial for delivering effective programs.

The Importance of Data Aggregation

To break down these siloes, companies need to focus on data aggregation. By consolidating data into one accessible platform, organizations can extract valuable insights more efficiently. We discussed tools like GuestXM by Black Box Intelligence (BBI), which helps aggregate restaurant data to provide a comprehensive view for operational decision making. Aggregated data is not just about convenience; it’s about making the data actionable and strategic.

Metrics That Matter

Understanding which metrics to track is essential for any data-driven strategy. Utilization data, support call frequency, and customer engagement levels are just a few examples. Interestingly, support calls could indicate either a highly engaged customer or a highly dissatisfied one, depending on the context. Hence, interpreting these metrics accurately is crucial.

Quarterly Business Reviews (QBRs)

QBRs are a staple in high-dollar solutions to remind clients of the value being delivered. However, to make these reviews impactful, organizations need to back them up with solid value metrics. What do customers truly value? This is where data on customer utilization, system downtime, and other incidents come into play. These metrics not only help in demonstrating value but also in identifying areas for improvement.

Organizational Culture and Data Disclosure

Another critical aspect we touched upon is the role of organizational culture in data disclosure. For data to be genuinely effective, there needs to be a culture of transparency and psychological safety. Leaders play a pivotal role in fostering this environment. They need to be aware of what’s happening within their teams and be willing to act on the data disclosed. This kind of culture encourages employees to share insights and challenges openly, leading to more robust data collection and utilization.

Steps to Organizing Data

Organizing data is a multi-step process:

  1. Align your data needs with your organizational objectives and the risks you want to mitigate.
  2. Identify what data to keep.
  3. Develop, enact, and monitor the ongoing utilization of policies around data retention
  4. Understand how data will be used, accessed, and most importantly, protected.

Once the data is organized, it becomes easier to quantify and utilize effectively.

In Summary

Data is omnipresent in every organization, yet its true potential is realized only when it is strategically harnessed. By breaking down data siloes, focusing on key metrics, and fostering a culture of transparency, companies can transform data into a powerful tool for customer success and sales enablement.
If you’re interested in diving deeper into this topic, keep an eye on this blog. I will continue – through open and transparent conversations with professionals who are making a difference in the world – to share more insights and practical strategies for leveraging data in your organization.


People Risk Consulting (PRC) is a human capital risk management and change management consulting firm located in San Antonio, Texas. PRC helps leaders in service-focused industries mitigate people risk by conducting third-party people-centric risk analysis and employee needs assessments. PRC analyzes and uses this data alongside best practice to make strategic recommendations to address organizational problems related to change and employee risk. The firm walks alongside leaders to develop risk plans, change plans, and strategic plans to drive the human element of continuous improvement. PRC provides technical assistance, education, training, and trusted partner resources to aid with execution. PRC is a strategic partner of TriNet, Marsh McClennan Agency, Cloud Tech Gurus, Predictive Index, and Motivosity.

Quick Notes: Unlocking Leadership Skills to Mitigate Performance Risk

Tiffany Simms, the founder of Living One Step at a Time, transitioned from a role as a senior chemist and leader in a Fortune 250 company leader in the nuclear power industry to teaching harmony between health, relationships, and leadership success. In this Quick Note, Diane Dye, CEO of People Risk Consulting speaks to Tiffany about various unhealthy impacts of leadership roles on well-being and what leaders can do to proactively address the overall wellbeing in their workforce during times of conflict.

Challenges to Address Up Front

  • Begin this practice without blame. It’s important to address challenges you are having within yourself as a leader and with your employees without blame. Blame confirms bias and blocks truth.
  • Recognize this is a practice loop of monitoring performance and ongoing communication. Develop employee skills and address stressors intentionally, not just at review time. Provide special attention to areas of improvement that will help them thrive in their role.
  • Executive burnout trickles down to front-line performance risks. Don’t skip lunch and practices for self-care. It will impact your ability to lead. Leaders must take care of themselves first and connect self-care practices to their daily routines to improve team organization and performance.

Align Goals and Values

  • Assess yourself more often than you assess your team. Utilize the skill of self-assessment as a starting point to make meaningful changes in your leadership practices.
  • Understand what matters to you as a leader and how you will accomplish the company’s objectives. Although it may feel like external situations run your day, acknowledging the abundance of choices you do have in setting priorities. Your plan of attack to accomplish the same objective may look completely different than other leaders’ approach.
  • Build your project teams intentionally. Align your personal and professional relationships with your core values and goals. Your role as a leader is to be the glue for talent, creating bonds that protect against performance risk and bind your team together.

Leading Through Change and Conflict

Clear communication is important to navigate and resolve conflict. Tiffany and Diane collaborated to share a framework to guide your conversations and maintain professional integrity and self-care in tense times where interpersonal risk is high.

  1. Clarity: Be really clear with yourself about how you intentionally want to show up for your team.
  2. Boundaries: Ask yourself – Where are your boundaries – your lines in the sand?
  3. Ownership: Can you own that with confidence? If you can’t, what within yourself is in conflict or dissonance with those boundaries?
  4. Discomfort: What uncomfortable conversations need to be had? What about this conversation makes it uncomfortable?
  5. Opportunity: Where do you have an opportunity to speak up?
  6. Gaps: Where are others remaining silent? What are the reasons others have for remaining silent?
  7. Risk: Weigh your interpersonal risk. What do you have to gain from speaking up? What is the potential loss?
  8. Communication: State your boundary in a calm, clear tone. Communicate with certainty, truthfully and with transparency to hold a space of interpersonal psychological safety in the interaction.
  9. Alignment: Seek shared vision. Make the conflict about the problem and not the person having the reaction to the problem.
  10. Example: Lead by example by guiding your team on how to address challenging situations using shared vision and effective communication.

Mitigate Risk Through Principles of Influence and Positive Interaction

  • Stay positive. Encourage leaders to focus on shared goals and influence positive outcomes in interactions
  • Lead yourself BEFORE you lead others. Emphasize the role of self-regulation and self-leadership when you want to influence interactions and achieve desired outcomes. Remember, you must lead yourself first before you lead others in the workplace.

If you need help navigating performance risk in your organization, connect with People Risk Consulting for a complimentary discovery call.


People Risk Consulting (PRC) is a human capital risk management and change management consulting firm located in San Antonio, Texas. PRC helps leaders in service-focused industries mitigate people risk by conducting third-party people-centric risk analysis and employee needs assessments. PRC analyzes and uses this data alongside best practice to make strategic recommendations to address organizational problems related to change and employee risk. The firm walks alongside leaders to develop risk plans, change plans, and strategic plans to drive the human element of continuous improvement. PRC provides technical assistance, education, training, and trusted partner resources to aid with execution. PRC is a strategic partner of TriNet, Marsh McClennan Agency, Cloud Tech Gurus, Predictive Index, and Motivosity.